Track Loader to clear trees? Pros/Cons?

Track Loader to Clear Trees? Pros/Cons?

Track loaders may not be the most commonly discussed equipment for clearing land, but they are versatile and efficient for this purpose. They offer significant leverage on trees, are useful for various other tasks like hauling fill or debris, and are particularly impressive for their size and capability. Check out these additional insights on their applications.

The Key Benefits of Using Track Loaders

Leverage on Trees

The leverage provided by track loaders is a critical advantage when it comes to tree removal. This built-in feature significantly cuts down the time spent on tasks like digging around the tree base.

Multiple Usages

Track loaders are not limited to tree removal. They can also haul fill to specific locations, pick up rock, handle demolished material, and even act as a makeshift man lift (though not recommended). With the right attachments, they can also be used for raking and digging efficiently.

Breakout Force

The breakout force on the bucket of a track loader makes popping root balls out of the ground a simpler task. This can be particularly beneficial in areas with dense tree cover.

Disadvantages of Using Track Loaders

Narrow Design

Compared to dozers, track loaders are generally narrower, making them less stable on steep hills. Their bucket is also narrower, which can lead to rocks and debris escaping the push, requiring additional cleanup.

Lower Traction

Track loaders often have narrower track pads with less aggressive grousers compared to dozers. This results in less traction and stability, particularly in challenging terrain.

Rigid Frame

Track loaders feature a rigid frame, which can lead to a rougher ride. The bucket’s cutting edge also follows the angle of the machine, making precise grading more challenging. While this can be mastered with practice, a tractor and blade may be needed for final cleanup.

Cost Considerations

In terms of cost, older track loaders tend to be priced lower since they are not as commonly used by contractors today. However, unexpected repairs can add a 40% premium to your cost. Going for the largest machine you can afford is often advisable as it provides better efficiency and capability.

I wouldn’t argue that an excavator with thumb is hands down the best, but it wasn’t within our budget at the time.

Final Thoughts

If you are contemplating the use of a track loader for tree clearing, weighing the pros and cons is crucial. Their versatility and leverage capabilities make them a potent tool, but they come with limitations like narrower design and less traction. For a more detailed comparison, you can visit Bulldozer Tree Removal.

For more information on land-clearing tools, you can check out our article on Essential Tools for Working the Soil.